Trauma and Physical Health

by Amazing Books

RESEARCH AND CLINICAL PRACTICE with trauma survivors has taught us much about the widespread problems of child maltreatment, partner violence, and sexual assault. Numerous investigations have documented links between such trauma exposure and long-term negative mental health consequences. We have also identified risk and protective factors for more resilient functioning. As we learn more about the psychobiology of traumatic stress, however, increasing attention has been drawn to understanding physical health effects of maltreatment and trauma (e.g., Kendall-Tackett, 2003). In a recent book reviewing this research on the link between childhood abuse and adult health problems, Kendall-Tackett (2003) describes a model that explains these links. She points out that much more needs to be learned given that the majority of research on trauma and maltreatment has focused on mental health symptoms.

The appearance of growing numbers of empirical articles addressing trauma and physical health coincides with an increasing interest in collaborating with professionals in medicine and nursing. For example, Frank et al. (2004), in Primary care psychology, outline important roles for mental health clinicians in primary care settings. Several sections of the book describe how trauma both directly and indirectly impacts physical health through its association with psychological distress. This book suggests ways in which clinicians with expertise in trauma treatment may partner in important ways with primary care professionals to better meet the needs of trauma survivors across the lifespan. Indeed, a recent article in Pediatrics (Borowsky et al., 2004) presents research on how primary care physicians can help prevent future violence and aggression when they screen for violence among children.

But where are we to go from here? Merrill and colleagues (2001, pp. 992–993) describe a useful framework for examining progress in research. Although their model focuses specifically on the field of child sexual abuse, it has applications as an organizing frame for the field of trauma, physical health, and primary care intervention. They describe three levels of research that need to occur for a field to move forward. Contributors to this volume have written chapters that fall within each of these levels. These are described below.

“First-generation” research aims to establish clear links between trauma and its effects across a wide variety of samples, for a variety of outcomes. This has been an important focus of research on trauma and physical health to date given that most early research on the short- and long-term consequences of abuse focused almost exclusively on mental health outcomes.

Most of the chapters that follow review the extensive and growing literature that establishes the negative impact of trauma on health symptoms and behaviors across the lifespan. Vanhoudenhove et al., Sachs-Ericsson et al., and Good Mojab continue this line of work in their explorations of links between trauma and health outcomes that have received relatively less attention, including chronic fatigue and pain, and postpartum health.

“Second-generation” studies, according to Merrill et al., are those that move beyond comparisons of victims and non-victims to within-group analyses examining factors which moderate the degree of effects that trauma has on outcomes. In their particular review of research on child sexual abuse, they discuss variations in characteristics of the abuse that may impact patterns of distress and resilience among groups of survivors. Chapters in this volume point to ways in which more work is needed in this area for understanding trauma and physical health. In particular, Banyard points to ways in which gender has been an understudied aspect of this topic and presents implications for both future research and practice. Further, the chapters in the current book demonstrate the impact of a wide array of trauma experiences on physical health, rather than focusing exclusively on child maltreatment as Merrill et al. do, or as was more common in early inquiry into links between trauma and physical health. This work encourages us to ask questions about how different types of trauma may be associated with different health outcomes and the need for different types of intervention and prevention efforts.

Finally, Merrill et al. describe “third-generation studies,” which aim to illustrate and gather evidence for processes through which trauma impacts outcomes. It allows us to ask questions about what variables may explain the powerful links we find between trauma exposure and physical health symptoms. Such research holds the key to important information for the design of effective intervention efforts. The chapter by Kendall-Tackett provides a review of two newly hypothesized mediating mechanisms in need of future study: self-efficacy and sleep deprivation. The links from such discussions to practice are highlighted in each chapter but particularly by Dallam, Stalker, and Hamberger, who describe guidelines for specific practices within primary care settings, that may address such mediating processes and help interrupt the link between trauma exposure and negative physical health.


Indeed, a key aim of the current volume is to make clear the relationship between both what the fields currently knows about trauma and physical health, and directions for future research as they may be applied to work within primary care health settings. The chapters ground us in a review of what is known while then asking the next set of questions and discussing real-world implications that the answers may hold.

0 comments:

Post a Comment